[OT) Elections - Was almost anything
jah.pigeon at ukonline.co.uk
Fri Dec 20 01:57:07 CST 2002
On Thu, Dec 19, 2002 at 09:38:07AM +1030, Brian Astill wrote:
> Pigeon wrote
> Saphologists?? What/who are they? A new protocol or a plant of some kind?
> >Those who study lesbianism, perhaps?
> No - that would be a lesbiologist :-)
> >>>Imagine every 5 current adjacent electorates combined, with electors
> >>>casting thir vote to elect 5 people in each such large
> >>>electorate. The
> >>>outcome would be likely to be a far greater number of minor
> >>>parties and
> >>>independents in Parliament, far more representative of the electors
> >>>views than is possible at present.
> >I'll have to think about this, must admit I don't quite understand
> >what's supposed to happen.
> Then who is it who's nuts? :-)
Well, what else do you call someone who thinks it's a good wheeze to
ignite a hundred litres of a stoichiometric mixture of oxygen and
acetylene, and allows pigeons to nest on his bed?
> Imagine each of the five original electorates would elect one Labour
> member with 51% of the vote. Labour would "win" 5 seats.
> Now amalgamate the electorates. 51% will now only guarantee 2 seats,
> but on a preferential system would probably "win" 3. The remaining
> seats would be allocated to the next most popular candidates - perhaps
> one Conservative and one Independent.
> Thus whereas before those who voted Conservative or Independent would
> not have their preference recognised, they would now.
> The overall result would almost certainly be that no one party had more
> than 50% of the seats in parliament, but maybe that's not a bad idea.
Oh, right, I get it. How to do proportional representation but still
make sure everyone's MP is reasonably local. I think you'd have to do
something a bit more complicated than simply amalgamating existing
electorates, but it seems like a reasonable idea.
Looking at Thatcher and Blair, I'm quite in favour of no one party
having an overall majority!
LinuxSA WWW: http://www.linuxsa.org.au/ IRC: #linuxsa on irc.openprojects.net
To unsubscribe from the LinuxSA list:
mail linuxsa-request at linuxsa.org.au with "unsubscribe" as the subject
More information about the linuxsa